Reinhold Law Firm
  • Our Attorneys
  • Our Staff
  • Practice Areas
    • Criminal Defense >
      • Nassau County Criminal Lawyers >
        • Nassau County Criminal Lawyers Mobile
    • DUI and Traffic Defense
    • Domestic Violence Defense
    • Drug Crime Defense
    • Juvenile Defense
    • Sex Crime Defense
    • Theft Crime Defense
  • Contact





Thousands in Prison Could be Innocent According to FBI’s Flawed Hair Analysis

4/24/2015

 
By Reinhold Law Firm

The Washington Post released an article last week detailing how 20 years-worth of criminal trials have included flawed testimonies regarding hair analysis from "nearly every examiner in an elite FBI forensic unit."
The government has identified around 3,000 cases that involved hair comparison analysis, and as of March 2015, around 500 have been reviewed. The FBI has stated that the purpose of these reviews is to "ensure that FBI Laboratory examiner testimony regarding microscopic hair comparison analysis met accepted scientific standards."

Yet based on what they’re finding, these standards have either been completely neglected or have very little validity.

In 95 percent of the cases reviewed so far, 26 out of 28 examiners with the FBI Laboratory’s microscopic hair comparison unit have overstated forensic matches in ways that favored prosecutors. 95 percent!

Decades in Prison and On Death Row

FBI Hair Analysis Reviews
The Guardian recently reported on George Perrot, a man who has spent almost 30 years in jail. He was 17 when he was arrested for the burglary and rape of an elderly woman in her home. The FBI found a single piece of hair on the woman's bedsheet, nothing more.

She stated that the intruder had short hair and was clean-shaven. Neglecting every bit of evidence that pointed away from Perrot - including the fact that he had long, shaggy hair and a mustache and goatee - that piece of hair put him in prison after an "expert in hair and textile fiber" from the FBI testified against Perrot, stating that it was his indeed.

These hair analysis testimonies have also sent inmates to death row. There have been 32 death-penalty cases with flawed forensic testimony.

An article released by The Daily Beast describes how Willie Jerome Manning, a man on death row for 21 years, was convicted of the murder of two white students through hair analysis back in 1994.

"Manning was a black man facing an all-white Southern jury, and the cards were already stacked against him. The prosecutor’s case relied on testimony from a jailhouse snitch and a woman who wanted to see her own criminal charges disappear—and an FBI expert who said a hair sample linked Manning to the crime. Manning was convicted and sentenced to death."

While both Perrot and Manning are still behind bars, these new findings of flawed hair analysis have provided them and thousands of other potential innocent people in jail with a ray of hope that their decades-long prison sentences will come to an end.

Related Article

Examples of How False Evidence Has Lead to Wrongful Convictions


Comments are closed.

    View All Posts >>

    Legal Updates

    Legal news, tips, and information throughout Florida and the US.

    Categories

    All
    Attorneys
    Cases
    Criminal Defense
    Drug Crimes
    DUI
    Florida
    Helpful Resources
    History
    Jacksonville
    Juvenile
    Laws
    Legal Advice
    Self-incrimination
    Social Media
    Social Media Legal Cases
    Theft
    Traffic
    Website
    Wrongfully Accused


The Reinhold Law Firm Difference

Our Jacksonville criminal defense attorneys at Reinhold Law Firm offer a safe, comfortable environment to help answer questions, relieve doubts, and provide solutions to those in need of legal counsel.

Duval County

Reinhold Law Firm
255 North Liberty Street Jacksonville, FL 32202
Phone: 904-354-2444
Map of Location

About Us

Our Attorneys
Our Staff
Contact Us

Practice Areas

Criminal Defense
DUI & Traffic Defense
Domestic Violence Defense
Drug Crime Defense
Juvenile Defense
Sex Crime Defense
Theft Crime Defense

Resources

News